BLOG | JUN. 11, 2025

Amateur Hour Mastering Desecration

So during the mixing of a project last month I asked the band who they had picked out to master their album. They told me about someone I'd never heard of who was doing the job for very cheap, and I said, "Good luck." When they forwarded a mastered song to me to see what I thought, I dropped the track into Pro Tools and compared it to the unmastered mix, bumping up the unmastered version's level to match and A/B with. Well, the new mastered version was louder but that's about all it had over the unmastered mix. It sounded like the track had been pumped onto and off a broken cassette deck. Highs were missing, low mids were ungainly boosted and the whole song sounded distorted. When I zoomed in on waveforms I saw the amazingly over-clipped scene you see above. (Top stereo track is "mastered" and bottom track is unmastered mix.) Flatlined distortion. Ugly. I mentioned this to the clients, and they agreed that it sounded pretty bad. It didn't take much convincing to send the project over to Tape Op senior contributor, Garrett Haines, at Treelady. Of course it's all sounding fine now. (I should mention that I still have no idea who the first mastering engineer was, so if it was you I'd stay quiet and start learning....)

clipped

if you're mixing a project, make sure to ask about mastering. I offer to do a quick check and advise on the job being done. I also recommend mastering houses that I have worked with before and felt they did good work. If the record comes out sounding awful, even if it's not your fault, how would a listener know?

Tape Op is a bi-monthly magazine devoted to the art of record making.

Or Learn More

MORE ENTRIES

New Jeff Tweedy song and video,  “Feel Free”

BLOG

New Jeff Tweedy song and video, “Feel Free”

By John Baccigallupi

August 25, 2025

Larry interviewed Jeff Tweedy of Wilco back in Tape Op#132 along with his son, Spencer Tweedy, and engineer Tom Schick at the band’s The Loft Studio...
Superchunk's new album, Songs in the Key of Yikes, is out now!

BLOG

Superchunk's new album, Songs in the Key of Yikes, is out now!

By Larry Crane

August 22, 2025

The new Superchunk album is here, and – no surprise – it rocks. I interviewed singer/guitarist/songwriter Mac MacCaughan way back in 2009 [Tape...
New Album from Raymond Antrobus and Evelyn Glennie: Aloud

BLOG

New Album from Raymond Antrobus and Evelyn Glennie: Aloud

By Geoff Stanfield

August 19, 2025

Raymond Antrobus and Evelyn Glennie [Tape Op#154] return with a new album, Aloud, part two of their spoken word poetry collaboration. Produced...
New Music From John Cale, Gunna, The Black Keys, and More!

BLOG

New Music From John Cale, Gunna, The Black Keys, and More!

August 9, 2025

There was some good music released this past week from Tape Op interviewees!John CaleMiXology (volume 1)John Cale [Tape Op#156] released MiXology...
Talking Heads Release More Songs About Buildings and Food (Deluxe Edition)

BLOG

Talking Heads Release More Songs About Buildings and Food (Deluxe Edition)

By Geoff Stanfield

July 29, 2025

Following their debut album Talking Heads: 77, More Songs About Buildings and Food found the band working with producer Brian Eno [Tape Op#85], which...
New Music From Jamie Lidell: Places of Unknowing

BLOG

New Music From Jamie Lidell: Places of Unknowing

By Geoff Stanfield

July 18, 2025

Larry Crane interviewed Jamie Lidell for Tape Op#129, and we chatted with Geoff Swan [#43] about Jamie's 2005 album, Multiply, for episode #27 of...
Gina Birch Releases New Album, Trouble

BLOG

Gina Birch Releases New Album, Trouble

By Geoff Stanfield

July 11, 2025

We interviewed Gina Birch for Tape Op#154 around the time of her 2023 release, I Play My Bass Loud. Her new album, Trouble, again produced by Youth,...
New Album Never Enough and “Seeing’ Stars/Birds”video from Turnstile

BLOG

New Album Never Enough and “Seeing’ Stars/Birds”video from Turnstile

By Corey Reidy

July 8, 2025

With assistance from Will Yip who we interviewed in Tape Op#151, along with A.G. Cook (Charli XCX, Caroline Polachek), and Jason Lader (Jenny Lewis,...
Paramore's Zac Farro Releases "1"

BLOG

Paramore's Zac Farro Releases "1"

By Geoff Stanfield

July 8, 2025

We interviewed Paramore drummer Zac Farro for Tape Op#144, and he hasn't slowed down much since. In addition to his work with Paramore, he has...