Interviews

Digital or Analog?: Multi-Channel Audio interfaces for your PC

When I first started recording music, my first purchase was a trusty and reliable TEAC 3340 4-track reel to reel recorder. That deck worked great for many years. I later upgraded to a Fostex 8-track, then a 16- track, then 3 ADATs and eventually an MCI 2" 24-track, that I run mainly with a 16-track headstack now. I love my tape decks. I love the massiveness and solidity of both the decks and the media that they record onto. Conversely, I hate computers. I think that's because I make my living with them doing graphic design and sit in front of them all day long. Nonetheless, if I was thinking about building a studio today, I would seriously consider going the tapeless route. Why? Well, for one, it's really cheap and storage mediums (hard drives, etc.) are getting cheaper daily. Secondly, a lot of the newer 24-bit 96k systems sound pretty damn good. Thirdly, as much as I like my analog decks, I hate maintaining and repairing them. Anybody who has an analog deck knows what I mean. Parts are hard to find and so are people who know how to fix them when you get in over your head. Computers overall, are pretty damn reliable and when they break, it's comparatively pretty cheap to fix or replace. And lastly, the combination of hardware and software that's available now is pretty versatile, but you already knew that from reading all the "Tape is dead" articles in all the other mags. I doubt tape will die anymore than books or movies died with the advent of television. But just as television changed the way people absorb information, computer recording will change how we record music in the future in ways that we can't yet entirely predict.

In this article, we will look at some of the different multi-channel hard drive interfaces in the $1000 and under price range and discuss the pros and cons of them. We've tested as many as we could get our hands on, but there will doubtless be ones we've missed or came out after we went to press, so consider this article a starting point and then do your own research if you want to dive into multi-channel hard drive recording on your PC. -John Botch

The minimum requirements...

...for a computer based hard drive recording system are a computer that is fast enough for what you want to do, a hard drive that is fast enough to keep up and has enough storage capacity, recording software and an interface that does Analog to Digital and Digital to Analog conversion (ADA). For this article, we are focusing primarily on interfaces that have at least four analog inputs and outputs that can be connected to an analog mixing console if desired. While you might get by with older, slower computers for stereo audio, for multi-channel use you need something a bit faster and newer. Luckily, computers are pretty cheap now. The first thing you'll need to decide is which platform to use, PC or Macintosh. If you already have a computer, this may be a moot point. Both have advantages. The PC is good because it's fast and cheap and there's a lot of good software and hardware available for PCs. The downside is that they're much more difficult to configure. Macs on the other hand are pricier and have less support and a smaller installed user base. At the top of the line, Macs are very fast and are easier to set up and use. Of the half a dozen people I spoke too while researching this article, the Mac vs. PC camp was split almost down the middle although there was a bias towards the Mac on the high end. Minimum suggested Mac Requirements are usually a G3 or better with 96- 128 MB of RAM, while on the PC side, you'll want a 250-300 mHz Pentium with 128 megs of RAM. The hard drive you record onto is especially crucial. I spoke with Bob Cacciatore at Xistor, a company that specializes in digital audio storage mediums, and he strongly recommends using a SCSI drive, because they're 'smarter' due to RAM caching. Ultra-wide is the best, if you can afford it and you'll want at least a 10 gig drive, preferably an external drive, with all of your applications and system on the internal drive. Crucial factors to address when buying a drive are seek times, density, rotational speed and data throughput.

Should you buy a Pro Tools system?

Pro Tools is the de facto standard for hard drive recording in most professional studios, much like two inch tape is for analog studios. Unlike most of the newer systems that use a PC for much of the processing and DSP, Pro Tools is an integrated and proprietary hardware and software system. With very few exceptions (See the MOTU section), you'll need Digidesign software and hardware to run Pro Tools. As this is a product with years of research and user feedback behind it, it works very well and has lots of support from third party manufacturers. So, if you want to be able to transport your tracks to other studios to work on them, for overdubs or mixing for example, Pro Tools compatibility is essential. On the other hand if you plan to be working primarily in your own studio and starting and finishing all your projects there, then Pro Tools is not essential. In fact, there are quite a few systems available for much less money and with even better specs that might work just as well or even better for you.

Do you need an expandable system?

Most, but not all, of the audio cards today are expandable. But, most of them will also require additional PCI slots, which can be a problem. (The work around is to get a PCI expansion board) Some systems like the MOTU will support up to three interfaces from one PCI Card. In many cases, it's a software issue. The Gadget Labs boards, for instance, support multiple units on PCs, but not Macs. This may change in the future and is mainly just an issue of driver development. This may also be the case with other units. This is something to look at on a case by case instance, as it's constantly evolving.

Will you need to sync to tape?

This is beyond the scope of this article, but be aware that if this is something you want to do then you need to make sure the system you assemble can reliably pull this off. Some of the options for sync are MIDI Time Code (MTC), SMPTE Time Code and word clock. Very few interfaces will read SMPTE directly which is how most analog recorders will need to sync up, so you'll need some kind of SMPTE reader/generator/sync box. According to several people I talked to, MTC isn't really reliable for digital audio; you should use word clock instead. If you're using MDMs like ADATs or DA88s, this is less of an issue since the ADAT BRC for example generates several types of sync tracks. Check the MOTU section below for more on this subject.

What Software And Computer Will You Be Using?

This will affect the audio card you'll need. Not all boards support all of the available recording software packages. Both PCs and Macs use the PCI slot, so in theory all boards should work on both platforms. But, you need driver software for your computer and your software. As new software is written and updated, this will constantly change. Make sure that the hardware and software in the system you assemble works well together.

MORE INTERVIEWS

King Tuff
INTERVIEWS · ISSUE #176 · Dec/Jan 2026/27

King Tuff To Tape and Back

By Chad Yenney

For 20 years, Kyle Thomas has been making rock 'n' roll tunes under the moniker King Tuff. Kyle has recently gone full circle, from moving back across the country to working on the same tape machine that he fell in love with long ago. Leading up to the release of his recent...

Julia Holter
INTERVIEWS · ISSUE #176 · Dec/Jan 2026/27

Julia Holter Making Materia

By Claire George

Julia Holter is a Los Angeles-based vocalist, songwriter, producer, and composer. Having released seven studio albums under her name, Julia has cultivated a unique body of work, following her instincts with equal parts precision and curiosity. Her lyrics read like poetry, and her lush...

Thao Nguyen
INTERVIEWS · ISSUE #176 · Dec/Jan 2026/27

Thao Nguyen Channeling the Loving Intelligence

By Meredith Hobbs Coons

Thao Nguyen is a multidisciplinary artist, best recognized as the songwriter and frontwoman for Thao & the Get Down Stay Down, and currently performing music as THAO. Even as she has been writing a book, penning a musical, contributing film scoring and film acting to Tuan Andrew...

Pamela Z
INTERVIEWS · ISSUE #176 · Dec/Jan 2026/27

Pamela Z Stretching Voices and Time

By Ian Brennan

Composer and performer Pamela Z has been pioneering live digital looping techniques since the 1980s. Her performances have been staged at such prestigious spaces as the Yerba Buena Center for the Arts (San Francisco), the Museum of Contemporary Art (Chicago), the Lincoln Center (New...

James Ellis Ford
INTERVIEWS · ISSUE #176 · Dec/Jan 2026/27

James Ellis Ford Look for the Silver Lining

By Larry Crane

As a busy producer wrapping up Pulp's recent album, More, in 2024, James Ellis Ford began to feel "like I maybe had burnout or the flu or something, and then my energy started to disappear towards the end." Diagnosed with leukemia and stuck in hospital, he diverted his...

Cabaret Voltaire
INTERVIEWS · ISSUE #176 · Dec/Jan 2026/27

Cabaret Voltaire Stephen Mallinder on 50 Years of Electronic Pioneering

By Alex Maiolo

In the first week of July 2023, a vinyl-loving subsection of Taylor Swift fans dropped the stylus on their fresh copy of Speak Now (Taylor’s Version). Expecting to hear a rerecorded version of a fan favorite about young love, these Swifties were instead greeted by a gravitas-toned...