Interviews

Tanya Donelly: Belly, Throwing Muses, Solo

In 1985, when I was 15 years old, my best friend's older brother gave me a cassette tape that said "Throwing Muses Demo" on the label. The first time I played it I was completely blown away — it was like nothing that I had ever heard before. But somehow the fact that the people that made the music on the tape lived two towns away made it seem tangible. I was already a home 4-tracker and budding songwriter, but the existence of this tape made it seem that I could make "real" music someday as well. Some 28 years later, through many serendipitous connections, I have had the pleasure of working with Throwing Muses co-founder Tanya Donelly as a producer, engineer, and collaborator. Beyond Throwing Muses, Tanya has been involved in the seminal bands The Breeders and Belly and has an illustrious solo career.

Can you give me an overview of the Swan Song Series?

Swan Song Series is a collection of EPs released digitally through my site and Bandcamp. They are collaborations, primarily with friends from over the years, but also with people that I reached out to, such as authors and other musicians that I admired but didn't know. I reached out to them to either write with me, or play on the music that I was making. There were also producers that I wanted to work with, such as yourself. Basically, the inspiration for this came from the Cabinet of Wonders that my friend John Wesley Harding puts together. At the end of those nights, people were reaching out to each other, saying, " Let's write something together." I followed up on those conversations almost immediately. The songs I wrote with Wes, Mary Gaitskill, and Rick Moody came from those events. From that point I just kept the ball rolling. That's where that was all born from.

Were you surprised how the results came out?

I was, and I wasn't, surprised. I went into it wanting to push my own boundaries and do something that felt more like a village of people making music together. That came exactly as I expected. I think that what surprised me was just the fact that when I went into it, I told everyone not to send me a song that they thought would sound like me. That was one of my prerequisites. I'm coming to these people because I like what they do, so I told them to send me what they do, not to try to tailor it to what they thought might fit me. Everybody pretty much rose to that, which was a happy surprise for me. I think it made the whole thing much more joyful and fun. For instance, if someone sent me words, I wrote music that I wouldn't have written in my own lyrical style. If someone sent me music, then the words that came out of me would not have come out otherwise. The whole process was really wonderful and engaging for me, in a way that I hadn't really felt in a while. Oddly, even though it was a massive project with dozens and dozens of people involved, it ended up feeling like a real community project in a way. It feels like a giant band to me. That's been really wonderful.

Do you think that the process itself created results that wouldn't have happened, had you gone in a more traditional direction?

Yes. Part of that is the fact that I wasn't just writing with other people. It was also the process of recording with so many of them. Sometimes I'm in the room when things are being recorded, and sometimes I'm not. That was a very different experience. I think there was more trust. For instance, Jacob Valenzuela from Calexico plays trumpet on a song called "Making Light." He came back with this beautiful, perfect part. That happened over and over again, and I feel like it was a very opening experience for me. I think it's difficult sometimes, as a songwriter and musician, to just say, "Here's my song. Do what you're going to do with it and I'll accept it!" There was not one case where I did that and was disappointed. I was just amazed by, and happy with, everything that came back. It ended up being a very successful experiment.

In a lot of ways, you had to act like a general contractor for these sessions, keeping tabs on the songs in different stages of completion in different studios.

I like that. That should be an official musical title. "General Contractor." It did feel like that.

You would send me an email and say, "Hey, are you available on this day? We'll do this piece." Sometimes it was even for pieces that we weren't working on directly.

I will say that the people that I worked with — you, [Paul Q.] Kolderie [Tape Op #22], and Scott Janovitz — were people that I already trusted implicitly from the production and engineering end of things. By putting it into the hands of engineers and producers who I could trust, and who I knew were going to get me something of great quality, I took less risk in that department.

How many different studios were part of the project?

Tons of them. A lot of people worked with their home studios as well and sent tracks in from their homes; like Chris Ewen did everything at home. It was really kind of all over the place. Probably eight or nine studios, at the end of the day. [See sidebar]

What was your methodology for keeping all of it organized and on time?

I didn't have any methodology at all. Any time constraints were of my own making, so it was very flexible. There were several times that I delayed a release because I was waiting for something to be mixed or mastered. The methodology was all over the place. It really went song by song. It depended on who was responsible for what, who was contributing what, and if we were waiting on a musician to finish a part and send the track. Every step of the way was just a very daily, organic process.

No project management software? No spreadsheets?

None. Nothing like that. Everything came together at Q Division [Studios], where I mastered half the stuff, and with Eric Masunaga [Modulus Studios] who mastered half.

I think the tightest one was something like, "I need this by Saturday." You were here on a Thursday, so I still had to mix what we did with Gail Greenwood [of Belly].

Oh, yeah. The one with Gail was the tightest one. It was hard to get Gail and I into the room at the same time for a while. Scheduling wise, not emotionally!

MORE INTERVIEWS

King Tuff
INTERVIEWS · ISSUE #176 · Dec/Jan 2026/27

King Tuff To Tape and Back

By Chad Yenney

For 20 years, Kyle Thomas has been making rock 'n' roll tunes under the moniker King Tuff. Kyle has recently gone full circle, from moving back across the country to working on the same tape machine that he fell in love with long ago. Leading up to the release of his recent...

Julia Holter
INTERVIEWS · ISSUE #176 · Dec/Jan 2026/27

Julia Holter Making Materia

By Claire George

Julia Holter is a Los Angeles-based vocalist, songwriter, producer, and composer. Having released seven studio albums under her name, Julia has cultivated a unique body of work, following her instincts with equal parts precision and curiosity. Her lyrics read like poetry, and her lush...

Thao Nguyen
INTERVIEWS · ISSUE #176 · Dec/Jan 2026/27

Thao Nguyen Channeling the Loving Intelligence

By Meredith Hobbs Coons

Thao Nguyen is a multidisciplinary artist, best recognized as the songwriter and frontwoman for Thao & the Get Down Stay Down, and currently performing music as THAO. Even as she has been writing a book, penning a musical, contributing film scoring and film acting to Tuan Andrew...

Pamela Z
INTERVIEWS · ISSUE #176 · Dec/Jan 2026/27

Pamela Z Stretching Voices and Time

By Ian Brennan

Composer and performer Pamela Z has been pioneering live digital looping techniques since the 1980s. Her performances have been staged at such prestigious spaces as the Yerba Buena Center for the Arts (San Francisco), the Museum of Contemporary Art (Chicago), the Lincoln Center (New...

James Ellis Ford
INTERVIEWS · ISSUE #176 · Dec/Jan 2026/27

James Ellis Ford Look for the Silver Lining

By Larry Crane

As a busy producer wrapping up Pulp's recent album, More, in 2024, James Ellis Ford began to feel "like I maybe had burnout or the flu or something, and then my energy started to disappear towards the end." Diagnosed with leukemia and stuck in hospital, he diverted his...

Cabaret Voltaire
INTERVIEWS · ISSUE #176 · Dec/Jan 2026/27

Cabaret Voltaire Stephen Mallinder on 50 Years of Electronic Pioneering

By Alex Maiolo

In the first week of July 2023, a vinyl-loving subsection of Taylor Swift fans dropped the stylus on their fresh copy of Speak Now (Taylor’s Version). Expecting to hear a rerecorded version of a fan favorite about young love, these Swifties were instead greeted by a gravitas-toned...