Did you go to a recording school at any point, or did you learn on your own?
I went to UCLA, but I have an English degree. My thought process at the time was that I needed something to fall back on in case the music thing didn't work out. And the music thing was very broad: I didn't know if I was going to be playing in bands or working in a studio. I didn’t know what that was going to be, but I knew I wanted to be in music in some capacity, and I almost didn't care what capacity. I still maintain that the worst day at any job in music is better than the best day at any desk job. I knew that's what I wanted to do, but I didn't think it was realistic. In hindsight, it would have been great to have gone to a music school or recording school – something that would have been actually applicable to what I do in my job now! [laughter]
I know. I wish I could sit down and map out every song on a piano just from hearing it once, but I never studied that.
Same. I've been self-taught in everything that I'm doing. Engineering, production, and music – I never really learned any of the technical or proper knowledge. I'm still fairly musically illiterate: I can't read music very well, and it's slow going if I do. Piano was my first instrument, so there was a time when I could kind of read, but it was never sight-read level. I went to UCLA, got a degree in English, and within a few weeks of me graduating and desperately looking for a job, I got a call to join a touring band, Reel Big Fish, and play drums, and make what – to me, at that time – was an insane amount of money. I jumped at that chance and never looked back. Luckily, I've worked in music in some capacity ever since then.
I heard you worked with Val Garay [Tape Op #112] at some point.
Yeah. He is the first producer I ever got to observe or work with. It was with Reel Big Fish. We were looking for producers and he stepped in. He was the first person who ever made creative suggestions – in terms of song structure and chord changes – that definitively made the song better. We were taken aback, “Whoa, that's what a producer does!" Before we went to the studio, he had a big API rack of mic preamps and EQs delivered to the rehearsal space. I asked, ”What do you need that for?” and he said, “These are the best.”
He’s got specific ideas about gear that he likes.
He came up in a different era, and a lot of the things that he mentioned still hold true. I did learn a lot from him, but mostly it was inspiring because I didn't even know what that job was, much less know anybody who did that job. It opened up this world of possibilities for me, and it inspired me to think, “Maybe I could do that.” One thing I love about production is that the window is open much longer for a producer. You can have a career into your sixties, seventies, or eighties. Al Schmitt worked until he was ninety-something, right?
Totally.
I looked at that and thought that could be a way into music, and to be creatively involved. I love that production is a bunch of these skillsets put together. I don't know that I will ever feel like, “Oh, I’ve got this.” Every time that I sit down with a different band I'm basically reinventing the wheel. Every band has a different set of circumstances, goals, strengths, and weaknesses, and I'm custom tailoring for every artist who walks through the door. Beyond that, for every song. How many times have we gotten a sound we think is sick, and then we try it on another artist and it sounds like dog shit? The challenging, frustrating, and also beautiful thing is that it feels like an art performance in itself. Every production you do is unique to that song or to that artist, and it's trying to crack the code of what's the best way to help this artist achieve their dreams or their ideas for the song. What can I bring to it to help elevate it in some way?
We're always changing our roles to fit. I was telling my assistant a while back, “It might look like I'm being passive right now, but I'm seeing where it's all going. I'm going to step in in a minute and it's all going to change. But I need to figure out how it's all coming together, and then I'm going to interject and make this better.”
Yeah, I feel like oftentimes the best records I make with an artist are not the first record but the second record, because by the end of the first record I truly know the artist. The barrier of comfortability is broken down and we're having a good time; I know their humor, and I know their strengths and their weaknesses. It's not until I get to the end of the first record that I think, “I wish I would have done X, Y, and Z differently. Now that I know, I would have probably approached it slightly differently."
Paramore would be a good example of getting into their world, right?
Totally. That was great in that I did every role for them. I started as an engineer [Paramore], then engineered and mixed the second record I did with them [After Laughter], and then I produced the last one [This is Why]. It felt good to earn my stripes, so to speak, and have them recognize what I was bringing to it. The level of the friendship is really high. I love them, and we're still in close contact with each other. That being said, I don't take those things for granted. I can't say that I'm going to be making records with them 'til the end of time, because I probably won't. But it's been a great ride. I cherish when I do have those runs with artists, where we do a few records together and develop a rapport that is efficient and yields great results.
Do you ever fear that it could get too comfortable, or veer too much into always working in the same way?
Yeah, I was thinking about that recently. There's an artist, Joe Newman, who's the singer of Alt J. He has a record out [The Canyon] soon under the name JJerome 87. We're very comfortable with each other. We're constantly cracking jokes and we have a great time. But with him, and even with Paramore, sometimes I wonder, "Am I crossing a line? Am I being too lax about this?" I do want to have a good time, and I think having a good time and having fun in the studio is paramount. We do our best work when we're relaxed, not when we're tense.
Music should be fun. That’s why we started doing it!
It's hard when people get in the studio. People definitely tense up, and they might start having a little bit of a mental freak out sometimes. Even with big artists. But sometimes I have to remind myself that we're not just here to crack jokes, we’re here to make something great. Even though I'm very comfortable with this artist, I can't lift my foot off the gas. I can't let things fly just because, “Oh, they'll understand. It'll be good.” I have to be constantly on guard and keep my blinders on, in terms of my focus – which is tough for someone like me because I do have more than a touch of ADD/OCD, and it's easy for me to get distracted. It is a bit of a challenge keeping the blinders on, keeping focused, and keeping everything on track.
Sometimes it's two tracks that you have to have running in your mind: One is the social aspect and keeping it light, and the other is like a manager or boss.
Yeah.
It's like, “This is all fun and games right now, but I'm seeing what I need to get done to get this finished.”
Exactly. Again, there are many hats you're wearing as a producer, and sometimes they're not as clearly defined. Some bands will have a person who's the taskmaster, and some don't have that at all.
And sometimes, as the producer, you've got to slow down the taskmaster person. I had a bandleader recently where I said, “I'm setting the pace. I will determine what we're doing next. I want a list of ideas, and I want to know how important they are. But I want the vocals done first.”
I.e. – what’s the most important thing? Like you said, there’s a social aspect, but there's a little bit of a therapist aspect as well. I don't know how many people have cried in the studio or had breakdowns of some type, but it's happened enough to where I’ve had to put on that hat and talk people off the ledge, so to speak.
I've seen everything. But the key is that we get through all those things, and at the end of the day the people that we work with appreciate it when it's handled well.
Yeah. One thing I always try to keep in mind is that these people are entrusting me with their art and potentially their livelihood. It's a heavy burden to bear, when you think about it. Their success or failure, or a part of it at least, is determined by how good this record sounds and how much people appreciate it. I definitely feel the weight of wanting to deliver for them and wanting to make something great for them. They're spending a lot of money oftentimes, and that isn't lost on me. I feel fortunate to be in that position; I want the opportunity to try hard and to make something amazing with these artists. I'm so thankful that I get the call to begin with. I try not to think about it too much, but it is something to consider.
I know that you worked at Capitol Studios for a bit. How did you end up there?
I met my friend, Greg Parkin, one day at a show, and he mentioned that he’d started working there. At that time, he was a low level assistant in the office. He said, “I think I can get you a job there.” I wanted to get off the road with the band I was touring with. I was over touring, and the idea of working in a studio like that was exciting. I got the call and I started there. I went from playing giant festivals and headlining shows and making lots of money to essentially being a runner and making coffee and fruit baskets every day. It was humbling, but it was the best. I was so excited to be there and to have that opportunity, even making minimum wage. The best of the best were coming through those doors. I got to see Al Schmitt every day. Green Day did American Idiot when I was there. Oasis came in and did a record [Don't Believe the Truth] with David Sardy [Tape Op #33]. We were doing orchestral dates; we did the Emmys and the Oscars there. Largely what I did there initially was setting up and tearing down sessions. I was lucky they had a janitorial staff so I wasn't having to clean up vomit or anything like that. But the sessions were pretty deep – you'd have upwards of 100 channels of not just microphones, but also lighting, headphones, stages, and gobos.
When you open up that door it makes a huge room.
Yeah. Between Studio A and Studio B. For that set up alone, I would get double and triple overtime. That was such an amazing opportunity to see all these legends walk through the door, both talent-wise as well as the engineers and producers. I’d get to pick a little bit of what I thought was great and combine it to make up what I do. It was the best for that. The house engineers were incredible. I learned so much from them. Steve Genewick [Tape Op #150] is the best. My friend Greg ended up becoming the head of the entire recording department after a few years.
Did you get to engineer there?
One day, I was on a mix session for a big band. There were all these legendary horn players in the room, and the engineer was Pete Doell. Great dude. At this time Pro Tools was definitely the industry standard, but there was still a lot of tape being used, and a lot of people were more comfortable with tape. There was a global edit that needed to be done – taking out eight bars of a trombone solo or something – and he wasn't sure how to do it. He asked me if I could do it, and I was like, “Yeah, sure.” I jumped on the Pro Tools rig and I made the edit. I was always pretty fast on Pro Tools, and I played it back in 15 seconds. They couldn't believe how fast I did it and how seamless it sounded. And the next day, my boss, Paula Salvatore [Tape Op #114] – a legendary studio manager – she said, “I heard you did that edit, and Pete said really nice things about you. I’ve got to start putting you on sessions.” It was one of those “opportunity meets preparedness” moments, and I started engineering on sessions there. But that was also short-lived, because at that same time I was building out my own studio, building my own little clientele, and I was starting to work with other engineers and producers here at my home studio. My entire time at Capitol was two or three years, but very quickly I realized that I didn't want to be a house engineer there. I wanted to do my own thing, at my own studio. The reality is that most house engineers don't get the credit. It just didn't seem as fulfilling or rewarding, or career-wise as smart. But I was getting my chops up. Having my own space where I could experiment was such a great way to learn and to develop my skill set. In combination with working at Capitol and seeing how they were doing things, that four- or five-year span of time was when I developed a strong engineering sense.
When your gear at home is limiting you, then you're going to have to work a little harder and sort out how to maximize that.
That's where a magazine like Tape Op was so great for me. I remember the [FMR Audio] Really Nice Compressor and the Really Nice Mic Pre – things that were affordable that were approaching pro level results. The techniques that you were talking about at that time helped me gain a little bit of an edge. I felt the people in the world of Tape Op were like-minded – they didn't necessarily have a ton of money, didn't have a lot of access to studios like that, but they had the passion. With a lot of passion and a little bit of know-how, you can do great things.
Were there other people that you knew in L.A. who were at your same level and building their own spaces back then?
Honestly, there weren't that many. That's one of the things I did that really helped my career path, because at that time not a lot of people had their own home studios. I look back on it, and that “build it and they will come” mentality – it’s so dumb; don't do it, kids! [laughter] It did work out for me, but it definitely wasn't a smart move. I had no business building out my own studio or buying gear with the level of clientele that I had at the time. But fortunately, it worked. This was the era of big studios and then overdub studios – where people would typically go to do guitar overdubs or vocals – were a little bit cheaper than the $2,000 a day rooms. My studio was a more homebrew version of that. I was also renting out my studio to friends who needed a spot. When you're starting out, you try anything and everything to make ends meet.
I assume this was facilitated by Pro Tools, in that you were able to have a place, run Pro Tools, and not buy a 24-track Studer.
Funny enough, I did buy a [Studer A]827 [24-track tape deck] and an [Ampex] ATR 102 [2-track tape deck] in the mid-2000s. They were mint. At that time, no one wanted it and nobody wanted to pay for tape, so they just sat in the corner. I was so bummed. Now, of course, things have come around again with tape, and I wish I had held onto them!
The old joke was, "Why does the studio have a Studer sitting in the corner? So, they can rent you Pro Tools."
Oh man, there was such a grift in Hollywood going on at that time where the engineers would buy their own Pro Tools rigs and rent them to the session. That whole era was insane.
They’d roll it in and say, “That's $10,000 a week."
Yeah, on top of their engineering fee. In a way we missed the boat. It's sad to see the industry collapse the way it has, but it's good and bad. It's so much more accessible to get into recording and get great results, which is amazing for most people. But the industry in L.A. has been kind of decimated in terms of all these other cottage industries, like cartage, rentals, and the number of jobs for independent engineers. All of that has basically gone away.
So, you built out a space on your own property, and you continue to go to other studios to do parts of the records as well, right?
I still do. I have a small studio, but I still enjoy live band tracking and I'm not set up for that here. I don't have enough isolation spaces. The dream is to have my own commercial space where I can build out my own studio, but it’s so expensive and I don't foresee that happening anytime soon. I do enjoy going to other studios. It feels like a field trip to me to go to Sunset Sound or EastWest and set up shop and record there for a week to track a band live. It feels like I'm exercising my engineer brain and the band’s excited, I'm excited, and all that energy is palpable. I like being prepared before we go in and do something like that. I'm not going to go into a $1,500 a day studio just to fuck around. Usually, we do a lot of pre-production, so the studio is more for executing a performance rather than experimenting. I don’t do that super consistently – maybe once a month for a few days or so – but it's fun, and it gets me out of my bubble here. Not every band has the budget to do that, so it's only when budget allows. I try to work on a sliding scale, and to work with bands of all budgets. If it's good and it's something I feel I can bring something to, then I'm down to work with whoever.
Are there smaller studios you can go to if you're trying to trim the budget?
Yeah. There's a place called Big Bad Sound here that's great for something small. It’s somewhere between what I have and where I would go in town. A lot of the studios right now are working with budgets of all sizes and shapes, so that's good to know. You'd be surprised. I don't think these big studios are being rented out every day, and they would rather work than not work, even if it means a few hundred bucks less than they normally would get. But I can do a lot here. My newest endeavor is writing. I got signed to Warner Chappell [Music] as a writer, and I've been trying to do more in that sphere and develop my writing chops. That's been a fun and challenging part of music making for me.
To co-write with people?
Yeah, exactly. And oftentimes those sessions turn into productions: I do a song with an artist, they like the process of being in the studio here, and we end up doing a record together. That's happened more than a few times. It's a great “first date” kind of thing.
We've seen it in our interviews. There are a lot of people that are working like that. Whereas that all used to be kind of a separate skill.
Yeah. I like being challenged, and I like working in different ways that I wouldn't normally do. For example, Warner Chappell had a songwriter camp in Las Vegas last year that I went to for the first time. It was some artists and a bunch of writers; you're paired with different writers every session and you see what you can come up with. It's challenging, in the best way. There's a chemistry to certain people in a room. You just never know where you're going to get when you're collaborating with people.
So, what's your space like that you have? Does it have its own restroom so people stay out of your home?
Yeah, it does. In the previous house that we lived in I was cutting drums in the kitchen and one bedroom was a control room, and it drove my wife crazy. Moving out of that house into a place that has a dedicated, detached studio space was huge. It has pretty good isolation between the tracking room and the control room, but that's basically all it is. It's a garage-sized drum room that I do everything in. I do vocals and piano in there. Usually, the players are in here for guitar.
You can do sessions that are an instrument at a time?
Yeah. For smaller budgets we have to multitrack it that way and build it up. I prefer live as opposed to multitracking, but there are definitely pros and cons to each way. I have to be flexible, be willing to anticipate change, and adapt to the way artists work.
How did you approach mixing Death Cab For Cutie's I Built You a Tower?
I have so many projects constantly going and I'm constantly bouncing back and forth between things, that to some extent I need to keep it in the box. Or I need to find a workflow that integrates a console that is not going to be as interruptive of my other workflow. It's tricky. I guess I could be a little bit more obstinate – I think there are some mixers who are like, “You have until 5 p.m. to send me your revisions and then we're moving on to the next mix.” But I want things to sound great, I want everyone to be happy, and I usually will do as many revisions as it takes to get to that point.
It's a hard balance.
I know it would sound amazing with my Rupert Neve Designs [5088] console, but I just haven't gotten to the point where I've been able to integrate it in the right way. So yeah, the Death Cab record was mostly in the box. I do have most of my outboard on inserts, and that's where I'm getting a lot of my extra flavor. I have a lot of outboard, and usually I'm printing it as I go because I've also learned the hard way that doing recalls and pulling it back up, it’s not the same even though the settings haven’t changed. If I have something that I'm going to use as an insert, I'll usually duplicate it and print it. I can always revert if it's not the thing.
I call it the "breadcrumb trail."
Yeah, exactly. But I love committing to sounds. I usually write in the comments what I'm using, as well as the basic settings. Right now, I'm thinking about the workflow of Chris Lord-Alge, where he has all his outboard and the settings never move. It either works or it doesn't work, and you move on if it doesn't work.
Just buy ten [Universal Audio] 1176 compressors – they all have different settings, and you patch them through 'til you like it. [laughs]
Exactly. That's what I'm working towards, and I'm far from achieving that!
To do this job well you've got to think hybrid. You can't be, "The only way I mix is…" I have different tiers of mixing, but I love attended mixing on the console.
I love that too. I used to be annoyed by attended mixing, and now it's the best way to get songs over the finish line faster. When people are in the room they are feeling more a part of the mixing process – they're contributing directly to the sounds of the mix, so it's much easier to get it done. It's great hanging with the band again. Usually, I haven't seen them in a minute; they come back and attend a mix for a day, and we get through as many as we can. I love doing my own thing and sending out a first mix. From there, maybe a second revision if it still needs a lot of work in certain areas. But at some point, I love to have the attended sessions to help get it over the finish line. The Death Cab record was tricky because those guys are spread out all over the country. Dave [Depper] was kind of the point person on the record. He was responsible for collating notes and sending me thoughts. Zac Rae, who's my longtime friend and who I've worked on a bunch of records with, is the one who attended towards the end. There were a couple that were tricky to get over the finish line, and he was instrumental in helping to get those fully realized. He's easily one of the most talented musicians I've ever worked with. He's just otherworldly great on keys and guitar, and he has his own killer studio with great gear.
John Congleton [Tape Op #81] produced this album, right?
Yeah. What an amazing producer and an amazing discography that he's worked on. He's here in L.A. We text here and there, and he's been nothing but really kind. His studio is incredible. It would be my dream to have a spot like his. John does incredible records.
When you got sent the sessions was there a lot of cool shit already going on? Obviously, John works that way.
Yeah, I think he works fast and loose, and there's some cool stuff happening on a lot of the tracks. It's always great to get a peek under the hood of someone's session and see the way they work. It's cool to see how they put the song together. I always try to take the vantage point of, "What can I learn from this person?" I've been fortunate to work with people like Joe Chiccarelli [Tape Op #14] and Justin Meldal-Johnsen [#93]. Anytime I have the opportunity to work with someone who's had a great career and whose work I respect, I always try to find what I can learn from this person. They're obviously doing something right, and I want to be better. I've never spent a day with Congleton in the studio, but I’ve worked closely with Justin and Joe. They're equally amazing.
One last question: The Linda Lindas. I didn't realize that two of them were your daughters!
Yeah. It's been a fun, crazy, unexpected ride with them. Now our family is a little bit like a crazy circus family where they're constantly touring. I go out with them when I can and we make records together. My wife does a lot of the day-to-day with them in terms of scheduling, driving them around, and trying to coordinate school. Mila, my youngest, is now dropping out of school so her load will be lifted a little bit. But there's a lot going on. We just wrapped a new record [Gotta Get Out]. They just signed to Warner [Music Group], and so far it's been a good team over there. We're excited to release a new record and see where that goes. We have some cool guests on it, and it was a really fun process of writing and recording that record with them. As a dad, I guess in my mind I always thought it'd be cool if the girls liked music like I do. I remember I bought a drum set for Mila and a guitar for Lucia, and they sat unplayed in the corner of their room for a good year. And then one day they had the opportunity to do a benefit show, and they played some songs with Karen O and Best Coast. That's how I met Best Coast and ended up producing their record, which is really amazing. They prepared for the show and rehearsed; they played very basic covers. They only played three or four songs, and after that show they got the bug. They were like, “Oh, I get it. I get what music is about. We want to do more of that, where you play in front of people and perform.” Then they were like, “Maybe we should learn how to play these instruments we have.” That was how it started. It was a fun, weird, opportunity and they have been together ever since. It's been five or six years now. We just made our third record, and they have a whole tour planned – they're playing festivals and flying all over the world. It’s crazy and totally unexpected. They did some shows with the Yeah Yeah Yeahs, Paramore, and Green Day. They opened up for the Rolling Stones.
What? I didn’t know that!
It's been really incredible to see them grow, and to see the world through their eyes: The first time being in the studio, the first time playing a late night show. It's been incredible.
Do you take them out to studios for the tracking?
Yeah. We've gone to EastWest, Henson, and Sunset Sound. For this new one we went to Studio 606 and NRG [Recording Studios]. When Capitol opens back up again, I definitely want to go back home and have them work in the place where I started my recording career. That'd be a nice full circle moment. But I try to give them that experience. They love that way of recording, playing live, and trying to execute well. They have a blast. They're at the age where they don't have bills to pay and they're still living at home. It's all fun and no actual responsibility, which is the best place you can be in life.

