I noticed you have the lead production credit on Show Me. You'd co-produced your previous album, Temple, with your former bandmate, Adam Thompson. Then these credits read, “produced by Thao Nguyen, co-produced by Merrill Garbus [Tape Op #88], Nate Brenner, and Eli Crews [#88].”
On Temple I was also in the lead producer role, but we didn't designate it as such. This time we paid better attention to how it was credited.
Merrill Garbus was the lone producer on A Man Alive.
That's right. Merrill produced the Thao & Mirah record, then she was producer on A Man Alive. At that time, I was starting to get more interested in that realm – it was just so sweet. Merrill wasn’t involved with Temple as much. I'm sure I asked her opinion, but, officially, she wasn't a part of making that record. It was so lovely to work with her again. Primarily, the big difference on this album was that Nate [Brenner] played a huge role. I've been friends with both of them for a long time, but over the years I hadn’t gotten to spend as much time with Nate. This time, just the two of us were in their studio for some glorious work weeks. Nate has this amazing work ethic. He's in the studio all day, every day, no matter what. Whenever I was home, he'd figure out how he could carve out time for me. Slowly and steadily, as we started to collaborate and build tracks together, it seemed like it made so much sense. It was such a relief to me to bring him onboard, and for us to get to work together. He plays bass on almost all of the tracks, and he co-produces in one element or another, but then he also co-writes on a few.
That's awesome. So, you adopted more of a collaborative approach to your writing on this album.
I did, yeah. For the first time. It was on the music side. Lyrically, I don't co-write, because I want to be a maniac about it – it's easier if I maintain full mania. With music, though, it was so lovely. For instance, we wrote that track, “Sick of the Times,” together. It has a little Moog DFAM drum synth hook I’d composed. I had that for months, and I was building around it, but I don't love building instrumental tracks and then writing to them. I can write more fluidly on an instrument, but sometimes I need a momentum and an energy that I'm not necessarily going to get on an acoustic instrument while writing. Nate is so good at music production in this way; building these tracks. He has banks and banks of ideas. So, for “Sick of the Times,” I sent the thing, two days later, he sent this instrumental track back, and I was like, "That's it.” Then I wrote to it. It was so fun for him to shoulder the load for a few of these. Normally, songwriting is more arduous. There were a couple songs that already existed as full instrumental tracks, and then I wrote vocal melodies and added guitar.
Nate and Merrill’s studio is listed in the album credits as BotCave. There's also a little spot listed called Loving Intelligence where you did your recording.
You might be the only person, by the end of time, who will have ever read these credits. [laughter]
I don’t know about that. There are a lot of nerds out there in the world!
But you're the first one I've encountered. [laughter] Well, I had to name whatever my weird home studio situations have been in the past, and I've been hopping around a little bit in the last two years to different apartments. So, Loving Intelligence – this is hilarious and I haven't told anyone this – was kind of a wink at Nate and Merrill, which they don't know because they definitely haven't seen the credits yet, and they probably won't see them. There's this dude named Dr. Joe Dispenza that Nate, Merrill, and I have listened to. I first heard about him through Questlove, who posted about him. He talks about manifesting and has these little MP3s that you can put on. He says you have to believe something you want is going to happen, and talk about it as though it’s going to happen or is already happening. Everyone's doing this now, but he's been doing it for a while. This was several years ago, and we all three really got into it. We still reference him, and in one of the meditations, he encourages the listener to thank the “Loving Intelligence” or whatever. So, anyway, that's what I do.
Naming a studio is inherently kind of funny, like naming a band.
Yeah, especially the slapdash situations. Naming this was a joke to myself because there's no actual studio. It's just wherever – but maybe that's the new state of the studio.
Loving Intelligence just exists. If one day a concrete studio evolves and it has a different name, then you can thank the Loving Intelligence and move onto the new arrangement.
It accepts you as you are. You can come; you can go. It's with you, no matter what.
I wanted to be sure to talk about how your values intersect with your art, because I know that's a big deal. You’re donating a portion of ticket sales from your upcoming tour to the Working Families Party. You've been making an effort to write from a more vocally queer perspective. It's interesting, because there's a subtler representation of your politics that comes through in the writing on Show Me that calls to mind Dean Spade's body of work and the influence of similar activists and thinkers.
I appreciate you picking up on that. Yeah, there was – on “Sick of the Times,” on all of it. It is woven in and a part of my worldview. The idea of movement building at a local, personal level is something that I take solace and comfort in. I'm greatly informed by all the organizing I was exposed to and able to be a part of when I moved to San Francisco, especially when I started volunteering with CCWP, which is the California Coalition for Women Prisoners. The organizing that I witnessed was so inspiring and beautiful, and that’s the true, gritty, hard work of what it is to be in movement work and to stick with it, whether or not there's media attention, and whether or not anyone at the national level cares. It seems like there will always be people at the local level who are part of a long, vibrant, robust tradition of organizing no matter what, and I do think it follows the example of the work Black women organizers have been doing for decades and decades. “Sick of the Times,” I wanted to serve as an emotional preparation for activism. When I wrote the album We the Common, it was for CCWP and the song “We the Common (for Valerie Bolden)” was written in tribute to the first person I met inside when I went on my first ever prison visit. You might not know what that song is about just by listening to it; you might have to do a bit of research. And maybe it's the same with “Sick of the Times,” too, because that's just the way I write. But I wanted the chance to have a hook that acted like a pressure valve, allowing us to be fucking sick of the times, but also not to check out. It’s not permission to quit, but it is an acknowledgement of what true organizing is and the sustainability of it. It's a song about how to navigate helplessness and how, as long as we all don't quit at the same time, we can take turns taking a step back and regrouping, which is important in all of these movements. There is this joy in being together. There is a reason that people gather. We are each other's only hope. The bright side is that it's the one thing that could change our situation.
This idea also shows up throughout your work in the collaborations you've sought out. The way that you approach making music reflects that collaborative spirit – that, “We're all in this together,” kind of politic that you have. Which is why I bring it up in the context of this interview: It's all connected. How has your approach to collaborating with people who've contributed to your albums evolved through the years?
The thing that stays true is that I'm a fan of the person, and I'm stoked that they said yes. It’s also a reflection of what was happening at the time the collaborations developed. Like, Joanna Newsom and I happened to be at the same songwriting residency (Hedgebrook, on Whidbey Island near Seattle). I asked her if she would collaborate with me, she said yes, and I was like, "That's fantastic.” So, it can happen like that. Andrew Bird, who was on Know Better, Learn Faster, was working on a record with Tucker Martine [Tape Op #29], who produced it. Andrew happened to be in town, and Tucker asked him if he would come in. I was a huge fan – The Mysterious Production of Eggs is a favorite album of mine – so I was too nervous, really, to talk to him. As it has evolved, my collaborations have been markers of friendship, admiration, and respect. On Show Me, I did make a special point of involving people I had been a fan of for a long time, or who I know by various degrees. Merrill is like family to me. She's always going to be welcome on an album if she wants to be, and a lot of “Sick of the Times” is me writing about our friendship. At the moment I was writing that, we were so despondent about Gaza, and we didn’t know exactly what to do or how to do it, but we could commiserate over that feeling. Then, I wanted it to be more of an intergenerational effort – and in movement building, it does have to be intergenerational to keep it going. So, for that little punk section on “Sick of the Times,” I thought of The Linda Lindas, because I love what they do. A cute story is that I know Martin Wong, Eloise Wong’s dad, from the beginning of my career when he co-founded Giant Robot, which is this Asian American music and culture magazine, and he was one of the first people to cover my music. I've always had a deep appreciation for him, and we've been friends over the years. When Eloise was four, he brought them to an in-store in L.A., and there's a picture of the two of them and me. I loved the sentiment of it, and they're so sweet. Then, my partner's kid was turning 12, and we took them and their friends to a Linda Linda's concert, so everything was full circle in this very sweet way. I wanted to capture that as best we could in that song. That's part of the story of that song. Neko Case [#127], who appears on “Catch as Catch Can,” is a real-life hero. I love the career that she's built. I told my first manager, when I was 23, “I want a career like Neko Case’s.” I've been able to open for her a few times; she's been very supportive over the years and made this collaboration happen, which was so sweet. She was so busy, and somehow made it happen. Adrian Quesada [#94], who's on “Nguyen Nguyen Lose Lose” is one of my favorite musicians and producers, and I recorded most of that song in his studio in Austin. I was living in Austin for a wild, wily time, and I built that track there and finished it when I came back to California. On Show Me, I had an interest in zooming out, showing gratitude, and taking perspective on the arc of my career. I wanted to capture some of these really sweet connections.
You had another unique collaboration on this album that you sourced even more widely than the others we spoke about just now – it was your collaboration with your fans!
The first single that we released, “Fossils,” is philosophically the true heart of the album. It's about trying to transcend self-protection. One of my life's challenges is to make sure that I don't prioritize defending myself too much. When I'm writing songs I'm thinking about performing them live, and I wanted an entire mass audience to shout these lyrics, for it to feel spiritual and life-affirming, so I thought it would be the best move to signal to myself and everyone what this album was about, so we posted an ask for submissions of people singing the chorus. Eli is the one that had to deal with all of the files. The first chorus, it was just Nate, Merrill, me, and maybe a couple other voices. Then I got a bunch of my friends to do it, and it builds a bit. Then we added in everyone who went through the trouble of sending in a submission. Some people sent videos – they're holding their baby, they're singing, it's very cute. I just wanted everyone screaming those lines, and I thought it would be a good reminder to myself, too.
Nice. Now gear stuff. I’ve read that you played your Moog DFAM, a Lowrey Pageant organ, and the Chamberlin M2…
There were so many different studio sessions, so it's probably easier to organize them by who had the instruments. The Chamberlin and the Lowrey were at Eli's Spillway Studios, near Hudson Valley, NY. That's a great place to record, and it was fun to play keys. It was a priority of mine to write a song on keys, because I love playing piano, but I don't write on it that much. The DFAM I've had for years. I had to place a moratorium on buying equipment a few years ago, because I went through a spell of, “I think I need that.” It was probably pandemic induced. Then I was like, “I have too many things.” I kept having to move around, and I was like, “This is too much. I have got to stop.” Now I just use whatever I have. I don't even go on Reverb.com anymore.
You are serious?
I'm serious. I've gone ascetic, if you can have way too many things and still be an ascetic. That's my situation right now.
But the Moog DFAM is on the roster of Loving Intelligence equipment, right?
That's right. I have a [Moog] Matriarch – I was definitely demoing a lot on that – a bunch of guitars, and a couple of basses. On the song “Close Up,” my go-to was this pedal chain that I would play everything through. I would even track bass lines and rhythmic parts all on guitar, because it was the easiest thing to do. The thing I hate most is getting caught up building the rhythm track. I'm passable at [Avid] Pro Tools, but I keep it basic and I don't plan on getting that much better. It just keeps me from getting the song down, and I have to remove every obstacle. It is so tempting to stop and look things up; then 35 minutes later I still won't know the answers, and I’ll have to move on when I didn't do any of what I needed to do. For this pedal chain, I was running a Roger Linn AdrenaLinn pedal, which I found in a guitar shop in Oakland. There was also the Strymon El Capistan, and a little Cry Baby Mini Wah (open), as well as an octave pedal. Or I’d swap out the octave pedal for a Mellotron pedal [Electro-Harmonix Mel9]. That combination is basically my tone throughout Show Me. I loved building out tracks and demoing to hear different components without switching around too much. Later, we would develop it in the studio.
When you're using your pedal chain, what are you amping it through?
One of the things I’ve let go of is using an amp. I've been going direct with all my guitar takes at home. We ran through an amp at Eli's place when we needed to hear the room a little bit more. But any guitar that I did on my own, I just went direct. I'm also sad, because I bought a [Fender] Princeton Reverb, an old one, thinking I would record with it, but a tube is busted and some wiring/grounding thing makes it very noisy. This is my predicament, generally, in life: Do I stop to get this amp repaired and lose who knows how long, or say, "Fuck the amp," and figure out another way? I'm not sure what the right answer is, but it's been out of commission for two years or something, and in the week that I'm home between things that I need to do, I can't spend my time on it.
Did you switch out the guitars you played through your setup?
I played different guitars through it. I played bass through it, but mostly I would switch between my [Fender] Tele and my [Fender] Strat, and then there's this old Italian guitar I bought, sight-unseen, from this shop in Brooklyn during the pandemic. It has too many problems to play it live, but I put it on the record because I needed something to justify that impulse buy. The pickups are weird and dirty-sounding, and I was just doing muted, percussive parts on it. I love percussive parts, where I'm muting the bass or the guitar. Those are my favorite things to play, and it helps me understand what the groove of the song is.
What is that guitar? Does it have a label on it?
It doesn't. It just says it's made in Italy.
Whoa! Because yeah, that is a blank headstock.
Then I have my [Fender] short scale Musicmaster bass that I bought in New York on tour once. I played most of the bass parts through that. When Nate joined on, we kept some of my bass for a couple songs, but for most it I was like, “You should just re-track that.” He’s such an amazing bass player.
What mics are you using to get your vocal takes?
The Neumann TLM 103 is the primary vocal mic I use when I'm doing takes at home. Maybe I've done a little bit through the [Blue] Baby Bottle, and also the [Shure] SM7B; a true workhorse. Those are the main pieces of gear I use.
Why use other things?
That's the reckoning. I’ve had the come-to-Jesus moment around, “What is it you do in this world? How do we make that happen? What are things that you can let go of? What are ideas of yourself that you have had that you can now let go of?”
Then it gets back to the philosophical questions.
Right? And I love going into the studio. I know it's expensive, and everything that I can do on my own I will. But there are things about workflow that are way more efficient in a studio with an engineer; things you just need to sound good and to be captured by a true professional.
Yeah, it's a balance. You're saving some money in your own space with the gear that you've invested in, then for other stuff – it's like doing your hair at home versus having someone else do it for you.
That's right. It's like before you start your album cycle, you’ve got to go get a professional haircut. But, until then… I will say that Nate and Merrill are inspiring because they are great musicians and self-taught engineers. The way that they've embraced engineering and have leveled up is really cool. I'm so happy for them, and I am so glad I get to go to their studio.
It's interesting the way that you layer your vocals. I was listening to your songs all weekend and showing my daughter your videos – I'm not even kidding; my kids have been raised on your music. One of the ways that I recognized I was pregnant with my daughter was when "We the Common” made me cry all of a sudden. I was like, "That doesn't usually happen.”
Oh wow! That's amazing. Thanks for having me along for the ride.
I mean, you'd want to hear that, right? What value does it hold for me to pretend that none of that exists while I'm talking to you? It makes me feel cool for having restraint. [laughter] But, you know, there's a song called "Fossils" that teaches us not to exercise that restraint…
I saw what you did there, and I appreciate that. That's exactly why I wrote it!
It's working! While we were listening to your music this weekend, my partner commented on how it sounds like the vocal almost distorts on the choruses, and I notice you do tend to layer your vocals on the choruses in a way that's not necessarily pretty, but full, with different timbres going on.
That is what we do, and it's more around the conveyance of urgency. In the choruses, generally speaking, I'm trying to land a point. Thinking about it live again, I want everyone onstage to know what they're going to sing – and everyone in the crowd, if they want to join in. In the songs where I'm layering in that way, that's my objective. I was raised Buddhist, and the idea of repetition and mantra is comforting to me. There's a reason I repeat things; if nothing else it's for me. Within the realm of musicals, if you repeat a line, there's got to be a reason. The actor has to think about why it's being repeated. I feel that way, and I've always felt that way. For me, the repetition hits differently every time – it's an opportunity to have another adjacent thought, or to develop an idea, but the repetition is part of how that can be developed.
That's interesting how musicals have led you to approach repetition with more intentionality, because I did notice that this album feels even hookier than some of your previous work.
That's good to hear. I've been working on the musical, and there's this film I wrote songs for. There’s also the book I'm writing – everything's happening all at once, somehow. I do think that my work on other projects was informing my editing with lyricism, and I've never been as honest about myself as I have been on this record, so it made more sense to use less words. I felt almost embarrassed about prior work. Because I couldn't say all of my truth, I put a lot of premiums on turns of phrase, like, “How cleverly can I present this thing?” I look back and wonder, “What was I trying to say?” And I wasn't trying to say anything. I was trying to hide or evade truth, but while still under the auspices of being a songwriter who writes about emotion. It's been funny that I make my living trying to communicate, and I couldn't because of all this internal stuff happening. Anyway, I'm a lot less afraid of space and silence this time around. I don't know if anyone can necessarily tell, but for me, I felt fine using fewer words.
Did silence come into play lyrically, as well as in terms of the sounds that you were including on Show Me? Was there lyrical and sonic obfuscation going on before this album?
There was. I think the sonic obfuscation was happening, because I'm afraid of silence live – or I have been in the past, as a performer. Out of every album, there are a few songs we never play live because they're slower and I'm afraid I will lose the audience, so I've always been high octane. On this album, "How I Needed You,” for instance, is a song where drums are a driving force. They're used as guideposts and punctuation marks, but then there's a lot of space and repetition because I wanted there to be. Will we play that live? I'm not really sure, but maybe I can help people settle into the groove and see what happens. I haven’t allowed for that to happen much at my shows.
What are some key things that you've learned along the way from the different co-producers and producers you've worked with? You've worked with some incredible people – John Congleton [Tape Op, #81] is an example that comes to mind.
Yeah, he was great. I thought about him making this album, because sometimes there were parts where I would do guitar takes and there would be a flub, but he would be the first to tell me if you lean into it, then it becomes intentional. Something I've learned, as someone who's been reluctant or shy, is to engineer for myself. I love to do guitar takes on my own, because I can't handle the pressure of someone just waiting. Even if it's Eli in the other room, and he's such a sweet angel, I can still feel it. I don't want that additional pressure of someone else waiting for me to figure out my shit. It’s too much. I love to do all my guitar solos and takes by myself. I often prefer to do my own vocal takes and vocal production. I think of it almost like a voiceover actor. I need to be on my own for that, because there are ways that I want to deliver everything emotionally, and inflections that I need to hit for my director self. I guess this musical has really seeped into my brain. But I will say I hate editing takes.
You’re a tracking engineer.
That's right. If we're in the studio together, we can just comp together. But if I'm remote, then I'll send four takes or whatever, and give times for things. The most important thing I've learned is what to let go of so that the actual take can happen. The precision around how it's captured, I'm a lot less concerned about. So much can happen in the mix; I just need to make sure that I'm capturing a clean thing. I used to spend a lot of time trying to cover more steps of the recording process. But, in the end, it wasn't conducive to me being a songwriter, which is my primary goal and mission. Over time, I've shed a lot of presumption around what I should be engineering and feeling fine about it. Before, I would probably force myself to watch YouTube tutorials or something, but I think I've found this great balance now of knowing what to farm out and what to do on my own. Before, I was trying to do so much of it on my own, but the product was suffering, and I was suffering. Keeping everything moving and keeping myself writing is what I'm going for.
Is there anything that you want to talk about in this interview that I haven't covered in my questions?
Only that it's such a great honor to be included in Tape Op. In the years that I've been recording, Tape Op has been a companion in every studio. One of the first studios I ever tracked in was Larry Crane’s Jackpot! Recording Studio in Portland, with Tucker. Anytime that I need to get excited about recording and making music, I read a few articles and then I'm back in. What is awesome about Tape Op is the same thing that I loved so much about getting to host Song Exploder. When I was at a loss or just had hit a wall, I had the opportunity to talk to people and learn about their processes, their own mechanical approaches to their craft, and to hear how much they loved what they were doing. It makes me excited again, and it makes me curious. It gives me this energy to explore what else I can learn, and it revitalizes my feelings around what else I can make. Thank you Tape Op for what you give us.


