How did you get into playing music and recording?
I started way back in elementary school, playing guitar, and I had a little karaoke machine that I would make recordings on. I immediately started writing my own songs. I never tried to learn anything else. I was writing weird little songs and recording them. In high school, I got into punk music, and we had a 4-track. That’s when I started taking songwriting seriously. I got myself one of those Boss BR-8 recorders, a digital Zip disk recorder. It's the purest of shit. It's got a built-in drum machine and all that. But I made my first King Tuff recordings on that, and it got me going. It helped me figure out multitrack and recording myself. I got the TASCAM 388 [1/4-inch, 8-track with mixer] after that. That changed my life. I connected with it in a way that I'd never connected with a piece of gear before. That’s where things started happening with the recording side. My first widely available record, Was Dead, was made entirely on the 388 and maybe a [Shure] SM58. That was the only gear. I might have had a R∅DE condenser mic or something, but no compression. No nothing: Just the mics plugged straight into the back of the machine and then mixed directly to a CD burner on headphones. That's all I really needed. Then I moved to L.A. and started working in the box and never had a fun time in that box. At some point, I got a 1-inch, 8-track. But the goddamn thing never fucking worked. I would track a lot of drums on it. For me, drums are always the most important thing to get on tape, and then I would do the rest in the box. I was trying to use that as much as possible, but I couldn't keep the goddamn thing working. Which is the price you pay. I'm proud of a lot of the recordings I have done. But, at some point, I was thinking, "I've got to go back to the 388." The second I got back to it, I was like, "Oh, my god." It was like I was in [the game] Candy Land. It's like you're operating a machine – automatic versus standard stick shift. We got a stick shift snowplow. I've been plowing a lot and I'm just working that machine. That's what the 388's like. A perfect machine that is just like a toy, almost. You feel like a kid again when you're using it.
Do you have access to a good tech in Vermont or do you do the repair work yourself?
I need to learn. I think there are some people hiding out in the woods here. I'm trying to figure out who wants to come here and help me, because everything is constantly broken.
When you started working with other engineers and producers, like Bobby [Harlow], did you learn anything interesting from a technical standpoint?
I don't know. I was so concerned at that point with getting the songs to sound good that I wasn't really paying attention to what he was doing. I found any time I've worked with a producer or someone like that, it's hard for me to learn unless I'm actually touching the stuff. I need to be messing around with the dials and hearing what it does myself in order to learn. I think recording is a hard thing to teach. Maybe some people can learn like that, but you just have to do it. I mixed a record with Shawn Everett [Tape Op #115]. I sat there the whole time while he was doing it, and I don't know what the fuck he did. [laughter] I was thinking, "Maybe I can learn something." I didn't know what that guy was doing. His hands were moving a mile a minute.
After years of doing this, what gear have you added to your workflow?
It’s interesting now, because I've gathered a lot of other gear. Now I have a [Neumann] U 47 and a lot of outboard gear that I'm using with the 388. It's cool to get that super high-end gear with this machine. But half the time I can't tell if it's any better than if I was just recording directly in. It's slightly different. I record five drum mics and then bounce them all to mono. That's one thing I think people don't talk about: Bouncing on a tape machine is what makes the sound. There's a certain sound you can only get by doing that. You're simultaneously losing information, but you're gaining some weird magical element. I start with that, and I build up from there. It's pretty straightforward.
Are you using other effects or compression?
Just raw; not a lot of compression. Only compression on the vocals when I'm recording them. Not a lot of effects either. My favorite guitar pedal is Mu-Tron Phasor that I got for $5 at a thrift store. That reappears throughout my discography. I also have a Moog MF Delay slapback on the on the effects bus. That's about it. You get to a point where it's just too much. The key is to have as little going on as possible. That was my problem with computers; it's endless. It's like a restaurant with everything on the menu. I need to be forced into the decision making.
What lessons has the 388 taught you that can be applied to other technology?
I think trying to get the sound as close to what you want going in is the main thing. You don't want to be adding shit later. You don't want to make decisions later. Make the decision as it's happening. Mixing should just be levels and panning. My problem with the computer is that it doesn't sound cool instantaneously. You have to put shit on it to make it sound cool. The machines just have a sound. It's instantaneous; it's limited in ways, but it sounds cool.
Is there anything else about recording you wanted to talk about?
Playlists are lame, comp’ing is lame, Auto-Tune is lame. Noise reduction is lame. Don't try too hard. Try hard to make a good song. That's all that matters. Stop trying to make everything sound big. I don't want to listen to big shit. Even listening to Led Zeppelin compared to a modern recording, they sound small. I want something I can listen to over and over again. Everyone's trying to make these epic recordings, and it's like, "I can't listen to that." Maybe once.
Let's talk about your approach to recording other artists.
When I get into producing someone else, I treat it like my own record. I get obsessed with it in the same way. The person I've done that the most with is Morgan Nagler, whose record [I've Got Nothing to Lose, and I'm Losing It] is out. We worked on that from the ground up, and I wrote the songs with her. I think what I bring as a producer is songwriting and some arrangement type stuff. I don't know what the fuck I'm doing as an engineer. I think that's kind of my strength too; I just turn the freaking knobs until shit sounds cool. But is it a good song? Because that's all that matters. A lot of my favorite recordings sound like absolute dog shit, but the song is good. Maybe it sounds better because it sounds shitty. Those are the recordings I come back to. A lot of modern music is so juiced up and high def. It's like high-def TV. I don't want to see all the pores on your face. I don't need that much information.
It’s been a couple years since the tragic passing of Dave Sweetapple. I’m sorry for your loss. Fans of Witch might wonder if you have any unreleased songs in the can?
We've got a whole album, and I'm working on putting it out. I'm happy that we were able to make that before he passed away. It's heartbreaking and so completely out of nowhere. But I'm thankful that we did that. We had that band together and it changed my life. But yeah, there is a final album. Stay tuned for that.
Would you say that he had been a mentor to you?
Definitely. He was the one that got that band together. He and J [Mascis, drums in Witch, Tape Op #27] were friends. Dave had a label [Tee Pee Records] and a record distribution [Surefire Distribution]. He moved to my town when I was about 18 and working in the record store. He moved his whole record distribution to town, which was unheard of in a small town in Vermont. All of a sudden, we had this warehouse full of experimental music and these cool, older freaks. It was amazing. They would have me draw album covers for them and do artwork. Dave, even though he didn't write the songs or anything, he really was the heart of the band. He was the reason it existed. I definitely learned a lot about putting out records from him. And just being a rascal. He was a true rascal.
Let's talk about the launch of your new label, MUP, and what spurred it.
It goes hand in hand with going back to the 388, and also moving back to Vermont from L.A. Just this desire to get back to doing shit myself. Coming from the punk world, making all my tapes and CD-Rs, screenprinting my shirts, and doing all that shit. Just having it be more connected. I missed that. It makes me feel more connected to the fans that I can give them something that I truly made. That's the idea behind the label, and to be able to put out my friends' music. I have so many friends that are the best musicians. I want to put those records out. I want to put out the record somebody made on their voice memos. It's that style. In this world, I have to figure out how to sustain doing this. Maybe shrink the operation, in a way. Find your people that are into it and do it for them. Make it special.
The last question is: What are you working on now?
Well, I just did my first real session, in my new studio here in Vermont, with my friend, Ruth Garbus. She’s played with me in a couple bands before, like Feathers and Happy Birthday. She's a true genius; a songwriter and singer. Her sister is Merrill Garbus of tUnE-yArDs [Tape Op #88]. Ruth is one of my best friends, and I can't even describe her music. It's one of a kind. That's really exciting, and it sounds great in here. I can't open my door because there's two feet of snow out there. So, I'm kind of trapped in here for a little bit.

