Interviews

Pamela Z: Stretching Voices and Time

Composer and performer Pamela Z has been pioneering live digital looping techniques since the 1980s. Her performances have been staged at such prestigious spaces as the Yerba Buena Center for the Arts (San Francisco), the Museum of Contemporary Art (Chicago), the Lincoln Center (New York), La Biennale di Venezia (Italy), and the Dakar Biennale in Senegal. She has worked with the likes of the Kronos Quartet and the San Francisco Symphony and was the recipient of a Guggenheim Fellowship. She also does voiceover work for films, like the 2002 documentary, The Weather Underground. She has released five solo albums (many of which she engineered and produced) and has contributed to 20 other compilations or collaborative albums since 1988. 

Early on you were a singer/songwriter. What led to your experimenting with noticeably modifying your voice?

There was a very specific moment. In the early 1980s, I saw someone using a digital delay during a concert. And that person was Jaco Pastorius. I was so entranced by how he built layers with his bass. Now, you can't throw a stone without hitting a looping musician. But in those days, no one was doing that. I went to a music store the next day, and I said, "I saw a guy who had a thing, and he played, and the sound came back." They said, "That's a digital delay." I said, "I'll take one, please." [laughter] Leading up to that I was trying to make more experimental music, but I was having a hard time getting past using the same tools that I'd always been using. All that I was managing to do was just make quirkier versions of what I was already doing. But when I started working with the delay, I began playing immediately with layers, while also thinking about repetition and process. Then I got multiple delays and started building things with out-of-phase loops. It changed my entire approach to composition.

Those technologies are so much easier and accessible now.

Yes. At the music store they told me that a pedal is going to sound terrible on your voice. He told me to get a rack-mountable digital delay. It had so little memory. My first delay had one second of delay, because memory was so expensive at that time. It was an Ibanez DM 1000. That was my first delay, and I quickly bought a second one. Then I moved up to spending more money and getting ones that had more memory. And then I bought these DigiTech RDS Time Machine delays that had 4 seconds and then 8 seconds. Eventually, I got a Lexicon JamMan that could have up to 32 seconds of delay. You're swimming in delay. That was so amazing. I always used rack-mountable delays, not stomp pedals.

How do you feel now, hearing so much that's akin to your pioneering work assimilated into the mainstream? 

I have to say that I've never used Auto-Tune in my work. Ever. When the first few people did it, I thought, "Oh, that's very interesting." But from then on, it was like, "That again? Really?" [laughter] "Is that all you guys can do?" Auto-Tune's never really been interesting to me. But what I did like about it were the strange artifacts that come from detuning things. I'd made a lot of work detuning of sounds, but radical detuning. I have these pieces where I've taken bird songs and pitched them down so far that it comes into the human range. Then I'm singing the notes that the birds are singing, and then I pitch it back up live. I have other pieces that are fixed media works where I make layers of sounds that are detuned, as well as time compressed and expanded. Sometimes with pitch correction and sometimes without, where the pitch lowers or raises with the time slowing or speeding up, rather than remaining the same note extended or contracted. I do that because I like those weird artifacts that come from adjusting the pitch in something without correcting the time or tuning, or vice versa. But I find a signature of pop music is that they tend to take one thing and run with it as if it's the end-all, be-all. And then something else comes into vogue, and then just that thing has to be in every song made, you know? 

Yes, that's so true. You also use some custom gear, correct?

Yes. Mainly they're gesture controllers. My main performing instruments these days are the combination of my voice and the electronics that I use. Those electronics consist of an [Apple] MacBook Pro with Max/MSP with a series of patches that use a lot of digital delay, granular synthesis, and all kinds of live processing that I do through Max/MSP of the samples that I play – most of which are banks of samples I've created myself out of found sounds, my own voice, and other people's voices. The MIDI controllers I use are all gesture controllers. Those were all built for me by a dear friend and collaborator, Donald Swearingen, who passed away last year. There is one he made that uses ultrasound.

Like the pregnancy scanning device?

Yes, exactly. It looks for mass. They're all sensor-based, so the sensors are all repurposed from other applications. Mostly medical, but some from the security industry. For example, the ultrasound controller uses ultrasound much like how they use in a hospital setting. I also use a controller that uses infrared light, and another that I wear on my hands that uses accelerometers (for measuring velocity) and magnetometers (for measuring magnetic fields). All of those sensors are looking for the X, Y, and Z axes of positions or movements of my hands.

I spoke with the late Stan Shaff for Tape Op [#146]. How has your recent work at the Audium in San Francisco, that he founded, allowed you to explore or do new things?

Well, the thing that was exciting about that particular residency is that I had won the Berlin Prize the year before. I had lived in Berlin for the first half of 2025, and my project while I was there was to make a piece called Arbeitsklang / WorkSound. While living in Germany, I went into a lot of different people's workspaces and recorded the sounds of the machines that they use to make their works. I also recorded interviews with them. My plan was to later build a piece. At the time, I thought it would be a performance work with fixed media and sampled sounds that I had made from these visits I did to factories, kitchens, and sewing warehouses. But I didn't have time to even start working on the composition while I was in Berlin – I mainly just made the recordings. When I got back, Stan's son, David [Shaff], had in recent years started this program of artist residencies at Audium. For a couple of years, he had been asking if I would come and do a residency. I finally said, "Oh, yes. Why don't I do this piece that I started in Germany?" I took all of those sampled sounds into Audium, and I composed the piece within that space. Audium is unique. I've done a lot of multichannel sound installations, but in most of those places that have multichannel sound, the speakers are all the same speakers. In those cases, it's 100 percent about the spatialization. But at Audium, the speakers are not all the same.

Right, they use 176 speakers of various quality and types that Stan collected over the decades.

Yes, and they are in banks of speakers that are all different from one another. Like, some tiny, tiny ones that have very high end, and then there's a big subwoofer, and then there are all these large full-range speakers. They're arranged around the space in sort of rings and sets that are mounted at different heights. The big thing about composing in there is that it's also partially about the color of the sound when it moves to different speakers. It's not just the spatialization, but it's a change in the timbre when you go from one kind of speaker to another. That was interesting for me, because I had to work within the space to compose the piece. I really composed it on that instrument – the sound theater itself is like an instrument. Fortunately, and unfortunately, it makes it not an easily transferable piece. One of the things I wanted to do was to send documentation of the work to the people in Germany who I interviewed, because I had told them I would send them the piece when I finished it. I thought it would be easy to make a stereo mix of whatever it was I did. But I can't just make a stereo mix of this particular piece, because it will not sound like the same piece.

Right.

We tried doing a binaural recording by placing the little head in one of the seats in the theater where an audience member would normally sit. The binaural recordings came out pretty well, but I feel like they lost something in presence. Those 3D dummy head microphones can capture some of the spatialization of the piece. Like, if you listen in headphones, you do hear the sound moving around behind you and from the sides, but I feel like somehow the quality of the sound has been dulled a little bit by having such small microphones mounted in those ears. I was missing the presence of the larger speakers in the theater, and how they actually sound and impact you physically versus the way that little microphones picked up all of the same signals. I didn't feel the crisp, cleanness of each of the individual sounds that were occurring in the actual space when I was playing the piece.

What was your first experience in a recording studio?

My first recording studio experiences were before I moved to San Francisco, and before I had really found my voice as an artist. I was recording these folk songs that I was doing and also singing on other people's sessions. That was in studios in Denver and Boulder, since I lived in Colorado at the time. They were 2-inch tape, 16-track studios. I did already know a little bit about sound engineering, because I had done a radio program for the NPR affiliate, KGNU. I had a new music program on that station. I learned a little about engineering and had worked with a board, but it was really fascinating for me and exciting to go into an actual recording studio and see how things work there, as well as to sing in a soundproof vocal booth and all of that. But when I first started recording my own work, that was after I moved to San Francisco. At first, I was just using a 4-track cassette [recorder].

Play video

Yes, same for me back in the mid-1980s.

I think mine was a Yamaha MT4X version. I lived in a flat in the Mission, and the deck was just in my back studio room. The room wasn't treated for sound or isolated, and I didn't have very high-quality microphones. I just had whatever mic I was using onstage to perform, and I used that same one in the studio. It was like a Shure SM58, but a kind of lower-end version of that. I used to create backwards tracks by recording and then flipping the tape (because 4-track cassette machines weren't designed to have a B side, due to all four tracks being recordable in one direction). In the 1990s, I moved into an artist building – which I still live in. A loft where I could build my studio. That was the first time I'd created a little isolation booth for recording. At first, I got ahold of an 8-track TASCAM reel-to-reel for tracking – I think it was the 1/2 inch, TASCAM 38. The technology started moving really fast at that time. I went from that TASCAM machine to an early [Alesis] ADAT, and then to Pro Tools. For a little while I used a poor person's DAW called Deck, before I could afford Pro Tools. That was my transition software between the ADAT and Pro Tools. At that time, Pro Tools was so expensive. I had $10,000 worth of Pro Tools in my studio. That was a lot of money, especially back then. That was my first sort of professional studio. That was around 1994. I had already been using Digidesign's stereo sound editor, Sound Designer II, before that. At the time, those software programs came separately. You could record and edit tracks in SDII and then import that audio into Pro Tools to make multitrack sessions. I was using SDII for sound recording and editing for a while before I got my hands on any other multitrack digital gear. But my first record, Echolocation, was a cassette-only release that came out in 1988. That was recorded on the 4-track cassette in my flat on Valencia Street in San Francisco.

What microphone do you primarily use now?

I have two studio mics. The mic that I use for performing is a Neumann KMS 105. The mic that I use in the studio is a Neumann TLM103. My other studio mic is an AKG C3000.

I know in your work you've used typewriters, glass vessels, spoken text from TSA pamphlets, and various objects. I was fortunate enough to interview the late composer Alvin Lucier for Tape Op [#130]. And I'm curious what you might have learned from him, and maybe other composers, like Pierre Schaeffer, who began his experiments with musique concrète in 1936.

The first Alvin Lucier thing that I knew of was the record of I Am Sitting in a Room. It was so funny, because I had it on vinyl. You had to stop and turn it over to be able to listen to the full 40-minute piece, yet it's a piece which is supposed to be experienced cumulatively. He had another album I owned called Music on a Long Thin Wire. Those were the first two things where I became aware of Alvin Lucier's music. In both of those pieces – and really in his entire body of life work – he was working with the ambience of a room and thinking about the reverberance of a space and how continuous sound is. I feel that listening to pieces like that seeped into my consciousness and gave me permission to make works that were long and had more depth in timbre and texture than they did in any melodic or rhythmic structure. I learned a lot from the so-called minimalist composers: Steve Reich [Tape Op #15], Philip Glass, and people like that. To play with repetition and play with slowly changing processes. That inspired me to work in a more expansive way. Coming out of my training originally as a classical singer I spent my college years singing opera arias and art songs by day, and then by night performing songs that I wrote in clubs. I had this way of composing music that was sort of based on a short songs model. Even when I started doing experimental work, all of my pieces were almost pop song length. Like short things that would have a beginning, middle, and an end, and they would have a format that'd be like the ABA form. There would always be melodic material, something that repeats, and something that layers. When I first started working with delays, a common way for me to make a song was to start by singing something that would get captured in the delays and would create a sound bed. Then I would sing a melody over the top of that, then adding something more to the looping, then singing another verse over the top of that, and so on. But then I became very inspired by artists who were building pieces that were much less formulaic. They were more expansive and structured in a slow developing process, or a building up of layers in more complex ways.

Play video

I was going to ask about your history of studying classical voice in college. That background is something very different than a lot of experimental artists – and also a lot of pop artists – who don't learn to sing technically before leaping into performance. How has your ability as an operatic soprano influenced your work?

A great deal. I think what is wonderful about it is that when I was studying voice in music school, the whole thing with classical singers is that the school of singing is based on the assumption that there is a good vocal quality, that there's really only one good way to sing, and that's what you should be going for. 

Right, right. A very rigid definition of beauty.

But that tradition also developed powerful and wonderful ways of using the voice. That ability is much more interesting to me, though, when it gets combined with other things that deviate. When I started listening to people who were doing extended vocal techniques, I began to realize that I can use every part of my voice – because I have an extremely wide vocal range. I'm technically a soprano, but I can sing the alto and tenor parts if I need to. It was a joy to be able to find music where I'm allowed to use parts of my range that are not prescribed – to use colors that are not part of the formal limitations, and instead to be able to defiantly take that technique but add it to all these other things. Now there's nothing that is off limits, in terms of what I'm allowed to do vocally. But classical singing technique still has a large place in the way that I use my voice. It's most exciting, though, when it's tempered with all kinds of other approaches.

For the work "Thank You So Much," I read that you couldn't record Adam Tendler's vocals and were past deadline, so you made the piece from snippets found on the internet, none of which were close mic'd.

Yeah, it was funny. I've been making a lot of pieces these days where I use speech sounds. I usually acquire those speech sounds not by sampling people off the radio or taking found footage. Instead, I interview people, and then I use their voices and I try to get as clean as possible a recording. If you're making a text collage that's made up of little chopped up pieces of speech, it's not even going to read if it's not a clean recording. Like when you hear somebody on the radio interviewing somebody in the field, often the recording's really noisy because they can't control the situation where the interview took place. But because those interviews are composed of entire sentences and paragraphs, it's still fine. But when you start chopping that into tiny fragments – just words and syllables – and repeating them and layering them; if it's noisy, it's very hard to make that work.

Yeah. We'll perceive the ambient noises more than the speech.

Exactly. I generally try to collect extremely pristine samples of people's speech. But in the case of Adam's voice, I was so behind. I was working in Rome at that time, and I didn't have the ability to record him in person. I was so behind on the piece, and I was embarrassed to call him and say, "I'm still making this." I thought, "I'll scavenge through every recording I can find of him on YouTube at concerts." I noticed that without fail, he would say, "Thank you so much," and he would often make a few remarks. But he wasn't on mic because these were piano concerts. The mics were in the piano, not in front of his face, so there would be all of this room sound and the reverb of the hall. I had no choice but to just work with it. I thought, "Well, I need to treat this more like it's just sound and not voice." I used that very reverb-y dirty sound that I found. There are a lot of places in the piece where you hear him say these same little snatches of things, and the color is a little different each time he said it. For part of it I've taken some of those phrases and stretched them to change pitch, or for time compression and expansion. I would expand his voice so that it was stretched, and I built layers that way. But it all came out in the end. It gave this piece an interesting quality that it would've never had if I'd had only pristine recordings of him.

Making something out of whatever you had to work with work, regardless – where the given elements themself become a creative catalyst.

Exactly. Just playing with the actual dirtiness of the sound. Sometimes we go in now and we try to degenerate the sound a little bit – to make it sound like it was coming through a bad telephone line or out of old radio speakers. We often go to all these lengths to EQ things – to turn them into "bad" sounds when they started out as really pristine. But this was muddied from the start, so I just followed it further.⁠Tape Op Reel

<pamelaz.com>

Ian Brennan is a Grammy-winning music producer who has recorded over 50 records, in the field, by international artists across five continents (Africa, Europe, North America, South America, Asia). He frequently writes for Tape Op, and his 11th book, Music from the Margins: The Cultural Crime Scene of Mass Media, will be published in the spring of 2027. <ianbrennan.com>

MORE INTERVIEWS

King Tuff
INTERVIEWS · ISSUE #176 · Dec/Jan 2026/27

King Tuff To Tape and Back

By Chad Yenney

For 20 years, Kyle Thomas has been making rock 'n' roll tunes under the moniker King Tuff. Kyle has recently gone full circle, from moving back across the country to working on the same tape machine that he fell in love with long ago. Leading up to the release of his recent...

Julia Holter
INTERVIEWS · ISSUE #176 · Dec/Jan 2026/27

Julia Holter Making Materia

By Claire George

Julia Holter is a Los Angeles-based vocalist, songwriter, producer, and composer. Having released seven studio albums under her name, Julia has cultivated a unique body of work, following her instincts with equal parts precision and curiosity. Her lyrics read like poetry, and her lush...

Thao Nguyen
INTERVIEWS · ISSUE #176 · Dec/Jan 2026/27

Thao Nguyen Channeling the Loving Intelligence

By Meredith Hobbs Coons

Thao Nguyen is a multidisciplinary artist, best recognized as the songwriter and frontwoman for Thao & the Get Down Stay Down, and currently performing music as THAO. Even as she has been writing a book, penning a musical, contributing film scoring and film acting to Tuan Andrew...

James Ellis Ford
INTERVIEWS · ISSUE #176 · Dec/Jan 2026/27

James Ellis Ford Look for the Silver Lining

By Larry Crane

As a busy producer wrapping up Pulp's recent album, More, in 2024, James Ellis Ford began to feel "like I maybe had burnout or the flu or something, and then my energy started to disappear towards the end." Diagnosed with leukemia and stuck in hospital, he diverted his...

Cabaret Voltaire
INTERVIEWS · ISSUE #176 · Dec/Jan 2026/27

Cabaret Voltaire Stephen Mallinder on 50 Years of Electronic Pioneering

By Alex Maiolo

In the first week of July 2023, a vinyl-loving subsection of Taylor Swift fans dropped the stylus on their fresh copy of Speak Now (Taylor’s Version). Expecting to hear a rerecorded version of a fan favorite about young love, these Swifties were instead greeted by a gravitas-toned...

Carlos de la Garza
INTERVIEWS · ISSUE #176 · Dec/Jan 2026/27

Carlos de la Garza Passion & Know-How

By Larry Crane

Jumping into Capitol Studios as a runner years ago, Carlos de la Garza knew he wanted to quit being a touring drummer and spend his time recording. It worked. He's recorded, mixed, and/or produced albums for Paramore, Death Cab For Cutie, M83, Best Coast, Bad Religion, and many...