Interviews

Pete Caigan

BY Larry Crane PHOTOGRAPHS BY Nils Schlebusc

Pete Caigan, the studio manager and chief engineer for a revamped Utopia Studios Bearsville, is a longtime Woodstock-area resident and busy guy. Utopia is a multi-use space that is deal for video/film shoots, live recordings, album sessions, and more. The Lumineers recent album, Automatic, was tracked there with David Baron [Tape Op #164] and Simone Felice co-producing. Pete's had an interesting path to end up at Utopia, and I had to find out more!

What was your entry into recording?

I came up as a professional drummer through my 20s. In 1999, I got married and had kids. I was less into traveling, so I took a four-day class in New York City and became Pro Tools certified. I had no experience engineering, but I could run Pro Tools. I got a [Digidesign] Digi 001 at home. I called Jerry Marotta [Tape Op #33], who I didn't really know but I'd worked with a little bit. He had a cool, small studio he still runs in his basement called Jersville [Studio]. I always admired him as a drummer, so I called him and I asked if he needed any help with Pro Tools. He said, “I'm sitting here right now. Come over.” So, it all began. I ended up interning at his studio for about a year and a half. Just doing anything so I could hang out.

That must have been some good experience.

He had a second house that was the studio and everything was set up. It was really just for him and his projects – records he was playing on. We had an 18-mic set up on the drums that was fixed. We were doing a lot of drum tracking. And then bands were coming in – Tony Levin [Tape Op #33] was there a lot – and we were cutting rhythm sections for them. I got a lot of experience. Then, the main engineer quit one day.

In the middle of work?

No, he was cool about it. But there were definitely bookings on the calendar. One of which was Pierre Marchand, coming into town to have Tony and Jerry play on a Sarah McLachlan record [Afterglow] at Jerry's studio. Jerry asked me if I wanted to do it. I was terrified. He said, "Don't worry. You'll be fine." I did it, and the record did very well. I got a lucky break there.

You were engineering the rhythm section, but did you get to work on the whole record?

No, we just did drums and bass. I'm not even 100 percent sure how much of the Jerry tracks stuck. But that got me some credits and then I got busy after that.

With Pro Tools and being a drummer, do you feel that helped with building up your editing skills?

Definitely. I was always the go to guy for anything: [Digidesign] Beat Detective. Moving parts around. That was my forte in Pro Tools. It did help a lot with understanding rhythm and knowing how things should sound. That was a bit of a double-edged sword, I would say.

How so?

You've got to be careful about manipulating music, as I'm sure you know. I frown upon it at this point. We do it a little, of course, but it's so much more preferable to have the person replay the part.

Where did your career go after Sarah's record?

I started to get calls to work at different studios around town. Dreamland [Recording] was one of them. I was working with Joel [Bluestein], the owner there. I was working at Jerry's and a bunch of other studios in town. I had a small studio in my house called Flymax [Sound]. There was a lot of jumping around a lot of moving studios. Flymax has been in seven different spaces over 20 years. We did some cool stuff in my studio, like Bedouin Soundclash. I was still doing a bunch with Jerry for things on ABC television, and a lot of corporate gigs as well as music. I continued to play drums professionally, but it wasn't my main source of income. I rocked out at Flymax for about six years, but I finally felt it was too small. I was at a cottage on my property. Aaron Comess, [the drummer] from Spin Doctors, did a solo record there. The guys from Bad Brains were in there a bunch. But it was tight. Then Jerry was also looking for a new studio in 2008, and he went over to Dreamland, which had been closed for about seven years. Joel had kept it for his own private sessions. There's a cottage on the same property as the main studio there. Jerry asked me if I would come along to look at the cottage to be his new studio. We went over there; it was small and right on the road. But the caretaker let us in, and we're like, "What's going on in the main studio?" He says, "Nothing. Do you want to see it?" We went in there, and there was an API discrete console – one of the first Paul Wolff designs. It was off and hadn't been on in five years. Joel said anytime he turned it on, he blew up a module. There were magazines on the counter from 2001. Jerry's friends with Joel, and one of the people that helped get Dreamland off the ground in the '80s. He called and asked Joel what he would think if he and I started doing sessions there. Joel said, "You're crazy, but go for it." It's a gorgeous studio and a vintage gear paradise.

There's classic gear there.

So, we started to do that. We were bringing in friends and productions and having fun. We started giving Joel some money. He was happy. And quickly, a friend who's an engineer said, "Oh, can I bring in a record?" That happened a couple of times. Chris Coady [Tape Op #113, #168] came in and started doing records there. Fleet Foxes did some of Helplessness Blues [with Phil Ek (#29)] there. Then it was booked all the time. And I was the chief engineer, and I couldn't work there that much.

Other engineers were coming in?

MORE INTERVIEWS

Hidden Musics
INTERVIEWS · ISSUE #175 · Sep 2026

Hidden Musics

By Ian Brennan

By 2014, I'd already been transitioning for more than five years from working in traditional studios to almost exclusively doing field recordings overseas. As a result, I'd had some success with groups like Tinariwen, Malawi Mouse Boys, and The Good Ones. At that point, the...

Yves Jarvis
INTERVIEWS · ISSUE #175 · Sep 2026

Yves Jarvis

By Geoff Stanfield

Yves Jarvis is the moniker of Canadian musician Jean-Sébastien Yves Jarvis. His latest release, All Cylinders, won Canada’s Polaris Music Prize for best album of 2025, a record on which Jarvis wrote and performed all of the 16 tracks. Made entirely using Audacity and a half-broken...

Joe Boles
INTERVIEWS · ISSUE #175 · Sep 2026

Joe Boles Seattle Recording Pioneer

By Alex Kostelnik

In the mid-1950s, Seattle was host to the little-known music recording legacy of Jay F. "Joe" Boles. A fraction of his discography includes The Ventures, The Wailers, Cab Calloway, Big Jay McNeely, Buck Owens, The Fleetwoods, Robert "Bumps" Blackwell, Ella...

  Rostam Batmanglij
INTERVIEWS · ISSUE #175 · Sep 2026

Rostam Batmanglij Sonic Cinema

By Sam Retzer

Ever since Rostam Batmanglij burst onto the scene as a founding member of Vampire Weekend, he’s been known for his penchant for baroque and leftfield sounds in pop-leaning indie music. Fresh out of college, he handled production for the first three Vampire Weekend albums (Vampire...

Melina Duterte
INTERVIEWS · ISSUE #175 · Sep 2026

Melina Duterte Sharing Curiosity

By Danielle Goldsmith

Melina Duterte began recording her own music armed with little more than a laptop, a budget mic, and a fascination with how records are made. As Jay Som, she crafted a distinctive sound defined by textural, layered guitars, and soft, intimate vocals. Since then, Duterte has expanded...

Oli Jacobs
INTERVIEWS · ISSUE #175 · Sep 2026

Oli Jacobs Friends & Commitment

By Larry Crane

A graduate of the Tonmeister course, a former Head Engineer at Peter Gabriel’s Real World Studios [Tape Op#63], and now an in-demand mixer, engineer, and collaborator with Jack Antonoff and Laura Sisk [#135], Oli Jacobs has had a heck of a career path. He’s worked on records for artists...